League

Football: News, Teams, Scores, Stats, Results, Tables. Soccer & Latest football news – Tribuna.com

Sportsmail's Luke Augustus compares the three United legends to determine the best no.1 in club's history. - Tribuna.com

David de Gea, Peter Schmeichel or Edwin van der Sar: who's the greatest goalkeeper in United history? - Tribuna.com

90live_Mobile_Interscroll

Image result for peter schmeichel celebration 1999

90live_Mobile_Inread1

De Gea

David de Gea Quintana

David de Gea, Peter Schmeichel or Edwin van der Sar: who's the greatest goalkeeper in United history?

Degea had to put up wuth awful defence a lot more than Peter and Van Der Sar

TR1GG3R

Paul Chris

I have respect for all three but the kind of saves de gea has done for this club are out of the world. De Gea hands down.

Ujas Varia

De Gea wins for me.. reason is because the Great Dane and Van Der Sar had better defenders in front of them which ment they didn't have to save as many shots. All 3 have made incredible saves for utd but De Gea has by far made more important and incredible saves. You also have to think De Gea is younger then what the others were and therefore could still improve even more yet. We have to do what ever it takes to keep De Gea at the club because for me he is totally  unreplacable.

MarcTiger

ΑΘΑΝΑΣΙΟΣ ΖΥΓΟΥΡΟΣ

Nsamba Ismah Omusambaganyi

Bernard Costello

Mohapi Ramalale

glynn eblet

Sorry de gea but it has to be Peter schmiechal he was a beast and could not be stopped but edwin was also very good

Elvis K

A very tough call... as I’m a huge fan of all3. For me though the Great Dane was the greatest keeper I’ve ever seen let alone who played for us.

Ste Carpenter

De Gea not even in a same sentence with this two

Zoran Kapica

Socorro Dias

De Gea is 28 Edwin Van der sar came to United at 32. That tells you all you need to know.

Imo Chima

Shane Myhill

David DeGae is better because all the other keepers of united had a wonderful team. They fought with everything. Now we don’t have that same passion in the players. They are more concerned about themselves and social media. David is doing it all by himself. I don’t blame him for not signing a new deal. Where is the team in front of him to protect him from the elements of other team.

Mitch Henningham

Duncan Awili

Peter, Van Der Sar and De Gea in that order.

Anyam Christopher

vinny

Mr AbdulFatai Olugbodi

Ketu John

The 98/99 season especially the fa cup semi-final save against bergkamp tips it in Peter's favour for me. Edwin with his penalty saves in the champions league final makes him 2nd, and once de gea has a moment like this he will more than likely move up to 1st

monkey trousers

Biggest impact was Schmeichel. And the most successful. Van De Sar was a part of one of united's best ever defence. But De Gea may be more talented than the two.

Nasri Latif

De Gea has no defenders, he is d one. Did u watch de gea vs arsenal 2017 is 14 save, and de gea vs tottenham 2019 is 11 without defenders. If ur a Manchester united fan u will understand what am saying. He is doing it alone. Go & bye him defenders so he will be d number 1 in d world.

Million Million

Peter was the best he was unreal and dominated his box. Love all of them but I bet there are a few on here that never even watched big Pete in goal for us. The glory hunters came after Peter after we won everything

Nione E Griffin

I am like good Muslim married to 4 wives... love them equally!! 😊😊😊

Zanzigems Trading

Richard Roberts

Trevor Ward

Mentioning degea in same lane only confirms to me how fast manu forgets  haha Europa when manu was in shutters....Haha mour for me

Lydia Akol

They didnt have smalling and jones in front of them. 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂🤣😂😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Jbizzle

David Taylor

The great Dane every day of the week not only did he do it for Man U but also for Denmark as well

Horsey

Different times different game but with the Great Dane we had an extra player in the pitch he commanded his defence and even most of the team his distribution was second to none being able to throw a ball further than most can kick it he put fear in the opposition and could hardly ever be beaten one on one on his over all game I can’t think of a single area in which he lacked as much as I like DeGea you can always find a part of his game that needs improving but then that can be said of most keepers today

Gavin Brown

Ability wise, De Gea
Legendary status, Schmeichel because of his trophy cabinet.

OK BUDDY👌

Khalid Azmi

De Gea  is better then the others due to the fact that the defences what the other two had in front of them are miles apart in class! but there all legends

Jonathan Storey

I would say there getting better and better

jonah

Anjiru Zawo Kamenya

Ashir Abdulazeez Aya'z

If we can have Degea statistics during SAF era im sure it will be very different picture

Emmanuel Mshindo

Mohammed Dolley

Armah Rhykon

Blakii Dhe Major

1st Schmeichel then 2nd Degea and Van Der Sa

Ak 47

De Gea not yet there but will get there som day

Kenpik Ent

Dea gea is great. . But the other 2 won champion leaque 1999 and 2008 .

TENO TV

Für mich ist es David De Gea. ..Was er bis jetzt schon geleistet hat ist einfach atemberaubend...Er wird die beiden anderen in allen statistiken in zukunft in den Schatten stellen...Edwin war auch genial und ist einer der besten Torhüter überhaupt gewesen...Schmeichel ist einfach nur ein Verräter für mich von daher nicht bewertbar. ..Schöne grüße aus Deutschland

Basti Tessmer

101% DE GEA, its unfortunate his trophies won says otherwise

Ben Bruce 

Yusuph Malenda

Dr de Gea for putting so much effort for defense that sometimes is living dead

Evans Asiago

Nana Monaki

Rizwan Zulfiqar

Andrew Howells

Peter has proven all the way .DDG is still young and no doubt he will be as good as Peter if not better intome to come

Daniel Tan

I asked Paul ince once and he’s thinks degea

Ben Emslie

No. 1.Peter title wise, but honestly David is better as a player.

El Ono

De Gea is the best and the greatest. I respect all the guys but De Gea is the greatest.

Keron Black Coffee Thomas

Evds an ps had crackin defence in front of them.... Ddg has had cracks in his defence.... Ddg for me for the amount he has saved us from humiliation

Liam Mawdsley

We have the greatest goalkeepers in our history they all deserve respect

NKHUZI  ZABABA

Allan Bolton

De gea is the best his saves are just phenomenal

Phillip Francke

If we’re winning games in the now then who cares but they are all great and have all done something for the club in there own way CMON THE REDS!!

darren brickhill

Can't compare ....
Because De gea is not yet end. Still can improve and long ways to go.
In the history the two keepers were so special.
De gea is amazing and the best keeper in the world.

♧ROYAL SKY♧

How do you rate the best... Is it by number of clean sheets or number of times they saved United ? Or maybe titles ?

Akiel Moonsamy

We should not be comparing the keepers as they were and will be legend's in there own right

Jimmy D Oconnor

The two were good at penalty, while Gea need to master that in oder for him to be compared with the legendary Van n Peter

Ssentalo Charles Karoli

I don't think all you 15 year old's ever heard of Alex Stepney!!!

Mike Daw

Really hard one.. but in exam we have all of the above when all the answers are correct.  In there prime all of them are the best.. I love them all for there contributions.

sam denedo

Schmeichel  ,scored  with header  n won with us the triple,  so nr 1 is him then Dea

Dou Secka 

Kane A Sucre

If David stays until he retires, he will surpass all as THE Keeper Legend.

Gerry Williams

They’re simply the best 
They can’t be compared
They can’t be questioned

Olupitan Matthew

Lungameni Ya Tate Naxweka

Gzack Zack

Peter was scoring crucial goals as an additional potential, however the question is about goal keeping potential. Degea is a is a standout.

Hassan Baba

Schmichael for me just awesome which started man u era

Soib Patel

Seth Abitey

I can say they are better than any other keepers

RealMK

All are the best each did some amazing heroic saves at crucial times.🤣🤣🤣

Grama Actualités

Actualités